Res Gestae
Morgan, Edmund M.
Citation analytics
How this journal article sits in the citation network, derived from CiteLaw's graph of published opinions.
Citations by decade
Courts citing this journal article
Most recently cited by5
- 2018Carletti v. Commonwealth Pa. Commw. Ct.
- 1974Commonwealth v. Coleman Pa.
- 1950State v. Linton Wash.
- 1949Raborn v. Hayton Wash.
- 1946State v. Hart Wash.
Counts reflect decisions in the CiteLaw corpus and may lag very recent opinions.
Abstract
A multitude of cases creates chaos in this subject. Even so great a scholar and lawyer as Simon Greenleaf was unable to clarify the topic when the decisions were fewer and simpler. Mr. (afterwards Mr. Justice) Pitt Taylor, the author of Taylor on Evidence, copied Greenleaf word for word; but when in controversy with Mr. Chief Justice Cockburn over Bedinglield's case, had to confess that his text consisted of words "full of sound, signifying nothing". He insisted, however, that the definition which the Chief Justice had framed left him "enveloped in a fog, dense as that by which I am now, as I write, surrounded." James Bradley Thayer, after a consideration of the history of the phrase, worked out a very carefully reasoned theory which, it was said by his son, "stood the test of his many years of later study."' Mr. Wigmore, Mr. Thayer's most distinguished disciple, accepts Sir Thayer's history but completely ignores his theory.
And Mr. Chamberlayne, another of Mr. Thayer's scholarly pupils, only makes the "confusion worse confounded" in his voluminous work.