https://www.njd.uscourts.gov/sites/njd/files/pretrialorder%20camden.pdf
Hon. Matthew J. Skahill · U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey
Text
=== https://www.njd.uscourts.gov/sites/njd/files/pretrialorder%20camden.pdf === May 2009 INSTRUCTIONS AND DIRECTIVES FOR THE ASSISTANCE OF COUNSEL IN PREPARING THE JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY, CAMDEN VICINAGE 1.
ADDITIONAL DISCOVERY
When a discovery deadline is set forth in a Scheduling Order or Discovery Order, it is the clear order of the court that all discovery is to be completed within the given time period. Interrogatories and requests to produce should not be served so as to require the answering party to complete them outside the discovery period. Any applications for an extension of the discovery period shall be made prior to the expiration of the discovery deadline and shall initially be made to the court via letter request, in accordance with Local Civil Rule 37.1. 2.
EXPERT WITNESSES
In any case where a party intends to present expert testimony, the Scheduling Order will set forth dates by which each party must submit the information required by Rule 26(a)(2), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Any applications for an extension of the expert report deadlines shall be made prior to the expiration of the deadline and shall initially be made to the court via letter request, in accordance with Local Civil Rule 37.1. Any expert for whom such information is not provided in accordance with the Scheduling Order shall not be permitted to testify at the time of trial. The Scheduling Order will set forth deadlines by which expert depositions may be conducted, in accordance with Rule 26(b)(4), if the parties choose to take such depositions.
3.
JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER
The Joint Final Pretrial Order must be signed by all counsel and submitted to the United States Magistrate Judge in accordance with the directives in the Scheduling Order. Attorneys who submit a proposed Joint Final Pretrial Order to the court that indicates they have not followed the form and instructions that are provided herewith greatly impede the processing of litigation in this court and create burdens for the court and its staff which are unnecessary. A persistent pattern of conduct in this regard by any attorney will result in the imposition of sanctions. The Joint Final Pretrial Order is the most important order that is submitted to the court prior to trial.
A form of the Joint Final Pretrial Order, with more specific instructions, is attached hereto. It shall be signed by all counsel and shall reflect the effort of all counsel. It is the document that members of the court use for immediate reference to determine the nature of your case. The form given to counsel should be appropriately enlarged in cases where there are multiple parties.
In such cases, for purposes of clarity, wherever the form calls for facts, arguments, witnesses, or other evidence as to “plaintiff” or “defendant,” counsel should delineate the required information for each party or third-party, being certain to give the name of the party for whom the information is provided. The form is a guide. It is to be retyped and not used as a “fill in the blanks” form. Counsel shall make every effort to meet to complete the Joint Final Pretrial Order.
In any event, plaintiff’s counsel should complete plaintiff’s portion of the Order sufficiently in advance of the due date for the entire Order so as to give each defense attorney at least four full working days to complete the defense portion of the Order. When the Joint Final Pretrial Order is completed, it should be returned to plaintiff’s counsel, who shall be charged with delivering the original and two copies of the Order to the court, with sufficient copies for all counsel. The Joint Final Pretrial Order shall designate the assigned District Judge in the caption and shall be submitted on 8 ½ by 11 paper. Upon completion, it shall be mailed or hand delivered to: [Hon. ] United States Magistrate Judge Mitchell H. Cohen U.S. Courthouse One John F. Gerry Plaza Fourth and Cooper Streets Camden, NJ 08101 In the event the Joint Final Pretrial Order is to be delivered to the court at the Final Pretrial Conference, the Order will be reviewed by the Magistrate Judge at the conference and entered upon the record.
Another purpose of the Final Pretrial Order is to attempt to settle the action. For that reason, at that conference, each party must be represented by an attorney who is vested with full settlement authority. Clients are to be either present or on call so that any settlement proposals made at the conference can be immediately conveyed. Sanctions may be imposed for the unexcused failure of counsel to cooperate in submitting the Joint Final Pretrial Order when due, or for failing to obey a Scheduling Order or Discovery Order.
See Rules 16(f) and 37(b)(2) and (g), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Once the Joint Final Pretrial Order is entered upon the record, it shall only be modified in exceptional circumstances “to prevent manifest injustice.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(e). All requests to amend the Joint Final Pretrial Order shall be made by formal motion. 2 4.
FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
The date of the Final Pretrial Conference will be set forth in the Scheduling Order and shall be held in accordance with Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(d). If a summary judgment or other dispositive motion is pending before the District Judge at the time of the Final Pretrial Conference, the conference may be postponed until such time as the motion is resolved. Counsel shall inform the Magistrate Judge of such pending motion in advance of the scheduled Final Pretrial Conference date and may request an adjournment. 5.
SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES
Settlement conferences will be held prior to the submission of the Joint Final Pretrial Order upon the request of any counsel or upon Order of the court. 6. TRIAL DATE and PRETRIAL SUBMISSIONS TO THE COURT The trial date set forth by the court is firm. Any application concerning the trial date should be directed to the District Judge assigned to the action.
Counsel are advised that the failure to comply with an order setting forth dates for submission of trial briefs, voir dire questions, and requests to charge or proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law when required may result in the imposition of sanctions. 3 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY CAMDEN VICINAGE (Plaintiffs) v. (Defendants) Civil No. (Indicate Jury or Non-Jury) JOINT FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER The following shall constitute the Final Pretrial Order pursuant to Rule 16, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. This Final Pretrial Order shall govern the conduct of the trial of this case. Amendments to this Order will be allowed only in exceptional circumstances to prevent manifest injustice.
See Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(e). Counsel are urged to move to amend in a timely fashion any portion of the Order that must be changed or modified between the filing of the Order and the trial date. APPEARANCES: PART I. JURISDICTION and BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE CASE: Counsel shall specifically set forth the jurisdictional basis of this action, as well as a brief summary of the claims and defenses.
PART II.
STIPULATED FACTS: Stipulated facts shall be set forth in numbered paragraphs.
4 PART III.
EACH PLAINTIFF’S CONTESTED FACTS: 1.
Plaintiff intends to prove the following contested facts with regard to liability: 2. Plaintiff intends to prove the following contested facts with regard to damages: PART IV.
EACH DEFENDANT’S CONTESTED FACTS: 1.
Defendant intends to prove the following contested facts with regard to liability: damages: 2. Defendant intends to prove the following contested facts with regard to PART V. WITNESSES and SUMMARY OF TESTIMONY: Only the witnesses whose names and addresses are listed herein will be permitted to testify at the time of trial. For each witness listed, there must be a description of their testimony. Any objection to a witness must be noted by opposing counsel and for each such witness objected to, the name of the witness and the reason for the objection shall be given.
A. Plaintiff’s Witnesses and Summary of Their Testimony 1.
2. Plaintiff intends to call the following witnesses with regard to liability and anticipates they will testify as follows: Plaintiff intends to call the following witnesses with regard to damages and anticipates they will testify as follows: B. Defendant’s Objections to Plaintiff’s Witnesses: If there are no objections to any of the witnesses, defendant shall so state that in this portion of the Order. If there are objections to any of plaintiff’s witnesses, they shall be listed here.
C. Defendant’s Witnesses and Summary of Their Testimony 1.
2. Defendant intends to call the following witnesses with regard to liability and anticipates they will testify as follows: Defendant intends to call the following witnesses with regard to damages and anticipates they will testify as follows: 5 D. Plaintiff’s Objections to Defendant’s Witnesses: If there are no objections to any of the witnesses, plaintiff shall so state that in this portion of the Order. If there are objections to any of defendant’s witnesses, they shall be listed here.
PART VI.
EXPERT WITNESSES: Any prior Scheduling Order of the court concerning experts is applicable to this action and the directives of the Scheduling Order shall govern expert testimony in this case. Any expert not listed in this portion of the Final Pretrial Order shall not be permitted to testify at the time of trial. Additionally, the curriculum vitae of every expert expected to testify at the time of trial shall be attached to this Final Pretrial Order. The curriculum vitae or summary of the expert’s qualifications may be read into the record at the time the expert takes the stand, and no opposing counsel shall be permitted to question the qualifications of the expert unless the basis of the objection is set forth in this Final Pretrial Order.
No expert will be permitted to testify at trial unless all opposing counsel have received the curriculum vitae of the expert and the information required by Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(a)(2) as directed in the Scheduling Order. If any hypothetical questions are to be put to an expert witness on direct examination, they shall be written in advance and submitted to the court and counsel prior to commencement of trial. 1. 2.
3. 4. Plaintiff’s expert witnesses are: Defendant’s objection to the qualifications of plaintiff’s expert witnesses are: (The objections shall be referenced to the name of each listed expert.) Defendant’s expert witnesses are: Plaintiff’s objections to the qualifications of plaintiff’s expert witnesses are: (The objections shall be referenced to the name of each listed expert.) PART VII.
EXHIBITS
In this section of the Final Pretrial Order, counsel should number each proposed exhibit and upon receipt of the exhibit list of an adversary, opposing counsel should prepare a response to this exhibit list indicating as to each exhibit whether there will be an objection and if there is, the nature of the objection. Absent an extraordinary showing of good cause, ONLY THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW SHALL BE INTRODUCED AT THE TIME OF TRIAL. You are not required to list exhibits that will be used, if at all, only for impeachment purposes. Counsel are reminded that each such exhibit shall be physically pre-marked 6 corresponding to the designation below.
Copies of exhibit lists shall be provided to the District Judge and the assigned court reporter at the time of trial.
A. Plaintiff’s Exhibits 1.
2. Plaintiff intends to introduce the following exhibits into evidence (list by numbers with a description of each exhibit); Defendant objects to the introduction of plaintiff’s exhibit (set forth number of exhibit and grounds for objection).
B. Defendant’s Exhibits 1.
2. Defendant intends to introduce the following exhibits into evidence (list by number with a description of each exhibit); Plaintiff objects to the introduction of defendant’s exhibit (set forth number of exhibit and grounds for objection).
PART VIII.
LAW A.
Plaintiff 1. Plaintiff’s statement of the legal issues in this case: B. Defendant 1. Defendant’s statement of the legal issues in this case.
PART IX.
MISCELLANEOUS
Set forth any additional stipulations of counsel and/or motions on other matters which require action of the court. Set forth any notice required to be given under Rules 40(b), 609(b), 803(24) and 804(b)(5), Federal Rules of Evidence. PART X. NON-JURY TRIALS (If applicable) No later than seven days prior to the scheduled trial date, counsel for each party shall submit to the District Judge, with a copy to opposing counsel, proposed findings of fact and 7 conclusions of law. There is reserved to counsel the right to submit additional requests during the course of the trial on those matters that cannot reasonably be anticipated.
PART XI.
JURY TRIALS (If Applicable) No later than seven days prior to the scheduled trial date or at such time as the court may direct: 1. 2. Each party shall submit to the District Judge and to opposing counsel a trial brief or memorandum with citations and authorities and arguments in support of the party’s position on all issues of law. The trial brief shall be electronically filed.
Each party shall submit to the District Judge and to opposing counsel written requests for charges to the jury. Supplemental requests to charge that could not have been anticipated may be submitted any time prior to the arguments to the jury. All requests for charge shall be on a separate page or pages, plainly marked with the name and number of the case; shall contain citations of supporting authorities; shall designate the party submitting same; and shall be numbered in sequence. IF you have the capability, the Proposed Requests for Charge should be submitted on computer disk, Work Perfect format.
All proposed requests for charges shall be electronically filed, and a paper copy must also be provided. 3. Each party shall submit to the judge and to opposing counsel proposed voir dire questions. EACH OF THESE ITEMS IS TO BE FILED PRIOR TO THE FIRST TRIAL DATE EVEN IF THE CASE IS CONTINUED.
COUNSEL ARE ON NOTICE THAT FAILURE TO PROVIDE TIMELY COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQUESTS OF PART X AND XI MAY RESULT IN THE POSTPONEMENT OF TRIAL AND THE ASSESSMENT OF JUROR AND OTHER COSTS AND/OR THE IMPOSITION OF SANCTION. 8 CONCLUDING CERTIFICATION We hereby certify by the affixing of our signatures to this Final Pretrial Order that it reflects the efforts of all counsel and that we have carefully and completely reviewed all parts of this Order prior to its submission to the Court. Further, it is acknowledged that amendments to this Joint Final Pretrial Order will not be permitted except where the Court determines that manifest injustice would result if the amendment is not allowed. Attorney(s) for Plaintiff(s): Attorney(s) for Defendant(s): Entry of the foregoing Joint Final Pretrial Order is hereby APPROVED this day of , 20__. [ ] UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE United States District Court For the District of New Jersey 9