Fraudulent Transfer Law’s Forgotten Foundations

Fraudulent transfer law is one of the principal bulwarks of private law. Fraudulent transfer law, however, now faces a crisis. Courts have long assumed that it was easy to determine whether a debtor made a fraudulent transfer of its property. One could use traditional markers of ownership to determine whether the debtor transferred property to a confederate.

But today, most assets are intangible. Transactions happen in the blink of an eye, and they take place entirely on corporate books. Reliance on simple notions of what constitutes a “transfer” of property is wholly inadequate. Understanding what it means for a debtor to transfer property for fraudulent transfer purposes requires revisiting the foundational principles of fraudulent transfer law, a task that has proved elusive because one of those foundational principles has been forgotten.