Mulvaney v. Rivair Flying Service, Inc.
10th Cir.
Citation analytics
How this case sits in the citation network, derived from CiteLaw's graph of published opinions.
★Landmark AuthorityTop 1% most-cited · cited by 178 decisions
178
Citing decisions
6+
Courts citing
Citations by decade
38
38
23
22
57
1980s1990s2000s2010s2020s
Courts citing this case
Most recently cited by10
- 2026Charley v. United States
- 2026Bagby E.D. Okla.
- 2026Cage E.D. Mich.
- 2026Jacobs N.D. Ohio
- 2026Price W.D. Okla.
- 2026Tackett D. Kan.
- 2026Nursa, Inc. v. Optima Care Jersey City LLC dba Optima Care Harborview; DOES I–X D. Utah
- 2026Commercial Capital Company, L.L.C., CoreFirst Bank & Trust and OakStar Bank v. American Tow & Recovery, Inc. and Bryan A. Herron; American Tow & Recovery, Inc. and Bryan A. Herron v. Commercial Capital Company, L.L.C. D. Kan.
- 2025Lawson v. Gossman E.D. Mich.
- 2025Johnson v. Roscommon County Animal Control and Shelter E.D. Mich.
Counts reflect decisions in the CiteLaw corpus and may lag very recent opinions.
Opinion
dissents:
I respectfully dissent and would adhere to the Order and Judgment of the panel heretofore filed in the instant case on March 13, 1984. Insofar as the record is concerned, the trial judge imposed sanctions without giving any reason. The trial judge did state that the amount of the “fine” or “sanction” was based on a statement made by the Chief Justice in a speech at an A.B.A. meeting.
In sum, the record does not support the action taken by the trial judge, and, in my view, the majority has filled in the gaps.